Oaklandâs Lateefah Simon, following in Barbara Leeâs footsteps, âprebuttedâ Trumpâs creepy Tuesday address.
Rising progressive star Representative Lateefah Simon, who succeeded icon Barbara Lee to represent Oakland this year, wrestled with whether to attend Donald Trumpâs Tuesday address to Congress even after I talked to her on Monday. The first member of Congress who was born legally blind, and the first Muslim representative from California, Simon had been tapped by the Working Families Party to do a âprebuttalâ before Trumpâs speech.
âI think itâs my duty to be in this building,â Simon told me. âBut I surely donât want to hear his racist, misogynist rhetoric. I surely donât want to hear the lies that malign folks in this country who work the hardest. But I believe I need to be there. This is our house. The president is a guest.â
Then she switched tack. âIâm deeply struggling with that. Weâll see. I donât want to turn my back on my duty.â
In the end, Simon decided her duty meant attending, while other progressives did notâand some, like Representatives Al Green and Maxwell Frost, walked out early. But Simonâs âprebuttalâ underscored her belief that no matter the fireworks, she knew Trump wouldnât say anything at his pathetic speech that she couldnât predict. She was right.
Trumpâs horror show went as we expected. âAmerica is woke no more,â he declared, as though itâs better to be asleep. He bragged about tragedies heâd caused and tragedies to come. He told us âthe days of unelected bureaucrats are over,â as he hailed unelected DOGE boy Elon Musk.
He brought a sad array of âguestsâ whom he introduced as victims, including the family of poor Corey Comperatore, killed in the assassination attempt Trump survived in Butler, Pennsylvania, last summer. To be honest, the family did not look at all happy to be there, but I feel for them. Itâs hard to be happy after your husband and father dies, kind of inexplicably. And Trump hailed a young cancer survivor who would not survive under his administrationâs healthcare and research cuts, and who also did not seem happy to be there. It was awful.
Simonâs response highlighted her difference from other congresspeople.
She is the most effective national progressive activist you might not know: Sheâs run California social-justice nonprofits since the age of 17. Sheâs the daughter of a single mother from the Jim Crow South. Simon, who is a single mother herself, is a community activist, a widow, and a criminal justice reformer. Mentored by thenâSan Francisco District Attorney Kamala Harris, she moved into the DAâs office working for the Young Womanâs Freedom Center. Mentored by Barbara Lee, she wound up in her seat.
Iâm sorry some on the left donât like what they call âidentity politics.â Simonâs identities make her extraordinarily equipped to understand the needs of Americans targeted by the current administration. She is also a working-class warrior.
She talked Tuesday night of her life as a single mother, and also as a widow. âYou cannot fight cancer on a budgetâŚ. I know what it was like to rely on a death benefit after my husband died in his early 40sâŚ[and] to rely on SNAP benefits.⌠Donald Trump and Elon Musk and others have never had to put groceries back on the shelf.â
Simon looked ahead to Trumpâs ideal America, which comes at the expense of everyone but the rich, where âtheyâre cheating Americans out of a functioning budgetâŚwilling to cut cancer researchâŚschool classrooms with 60 kindergarteners. Working people into their 70s and 80s without a hope of retirement that they paid into their whole livesâŚ. [Itâs a] sicker and poorer America.â
Dystopia, unless youâre Trump and Musk. Thatâs the Tech Bro Network State utopia.
Popular
âswipe left below to view more authorsâSwipe â
Trump introduced Musk at the address with more warmth than he introduced his wife, Melania. This bromance isnât going anywhere, even though Trump is being diminished by it.
Eventually, Simon did walk out on Trump, about halfway through his tedious speech. Iâm sure Melania envied her freedom.
Iâd asked Simon ahead of the address how she felt about House minority leader Hakeem Jeffries urging decorum on his members, and seeming to discourage either a boycott or a walkout.
âI have a different job than leader Jeffries. His job is to drive us through this chaos. Trump has flooded the space with ridiculous antics. We all have different vocations here.
âAs leader, [Jeffries] is hardcore negotiating with Speaker [Mike] Johnsonâs office. He is being extremely disciplined with their talking points. In conversations with me, even about whether I should be in or outside of the chamber, heâs been extremely supportive that I need to lead in the way that I need to lead, and that every district is going to require the deep respect of our constituents and what they need from us.â
She hinted at a battle many progressives are agitating for: Resisting pressure from the fractured GOP congressional leadership to help them avert a government shutdown in the next 10 days.
âWhat leader Jeffries has told me is: We will get to March 14 and we will fight.â Meanwhile, she added: âI walk with my bullhorn, and my Bible and my Koran, and my briefings, every day.â
Donald Trumpâs cruel and chaotic second term is just getting started. In his first month back in office, Trump and his lackey Elon Musk (or is it the other way around?) have proven that nothing is safe from sacrifice at the altar of unchecked power and riches.
Only robust independent journalism can cut through the noise and offer clear-eyed reporting and analysis based on principle and conscience. Thatâs what The Nation has done for 160 years and thatâs what weâre doing now.
Our independent journalism doesnât allow injustice to go unnoticed or unchallengedânor will we abandon hope for a better world. Our writers, editors, and fact-checkers are working relentlessly to keep you informed and empowered when so much of the media fails to do so out of credulity, fear, or fealty.
The Nation has seen unprecedented times before. We draw strength and guidance from our history of principled progressive journalism in times of crisis, and we are committed to continuing this legacy today.
Weâre aiming to raise $25,000 during our Spring Fundraising Campaign to ensure that we have the resources to expose the oligarchs and profiteers attempting to loot our republic. Stand for bold independent journalism and donate to support The Nation today.
Onward,
Katrina vanden Heuvel
Editorial Director and Publisher, The Nation